Pinderkent

Joe Stump recently wrote about why he switched from PHP to Python. What he says is absolutely true. He nails down many of the problems with PHP, and also lists many of the benefits of Python. In the end, however, I think we can just sum up the comparison between the two languages as being one of comparing Python's professionalism versus PHP's amateurism.

When I describe Python as being professional in nature, I am referring to the emphasis on care, contemplation, quality, and doing-the-right-thing-even-if-it's-difficult we generally see embraced by the Python community. Like Joe mentions in his article, the language itself exhibits a high degree of sensibility, consistency and predictability. It has clearly been carefully evolved and grown, rather than having features and functionality tossed on here and there. It's a language developed by people who know what they're doing, and it's a language used by people who know what they're doing.

On the other hand, we've seen much of the opposite out of the PHP community. The language itself is a good testament to the general preference of that community towards doing things quick-and-dirty, rather than correctly and with care. It's full of quirks, it's inconsistent, and generally a jumble of differing ideas and philosophies. We've seen this happen with its standard library, as well. With the core platform having such poor quality, any software build upon it typically ends up suffering from quality and security problems, too.

It's no wonder that so many developers are moving away from PHP towards better languages and environments like Python and Ruby whenever possible. PHP is deceptively attractive. Sure, it's widely supported, and yes, it's got a large standard library. But it has many hidden and not-so-hidden costs, including horrid maintainability of applications written in it, numerous security flaws within critical code, and numerous hurdles towards developing decent software. Even if the perceived costs seem higher when using a more professional language like Python, in the long run it becomes the only viable choice when the alternative is something as amateurish as PHP.